Concealed carry does stop crimes, often without a shot fired, but many incidents go unreported.
Defensive gun use is real but hard to quantify, with credible estimates ranging from 60,000–120,000+ cases per year.
Armed citizens can change outcomes, including stopping robberies and active shooter attacks.
Legal and civil risks remain, even when self-defense is justified.
Concealed carry is a personal safety choice, balancing deterrence, responsibility, and legal awareness.
Introduction: Defining the Question
Does concealed carry actually prevent crime? Supporters point to thousands of cases where ordinary citizens stop robberies, assaults, or even mass shootings.
Opponents argue those numbers are exaggerated or unreliable.
The truth lies somewhere in between, and it depends on how we define a “crime stopped.”
What Counts as a Crime “Stopped” by Concealed Carry?
Not every defensive gun use involves pulling a trigger. In fact, the majority do not. Many cases end with a defensive display— the victim shows a firearm, and the criminal backs off. Other cases involve shots fired, sometimes resulting in a justifiable homicide ruling.
The difference matters. Police reports usually document shootings, but they rarely track incidents where a firearm was displayed and no shot was fired. That gap explains why estimates of defensive gun use vary so widely, among other factors.
Concealed Carry Crime Prevention Statistics
The data tells very different stories depending on the source:
National Crime Victimization Survey (NCVS): Roughly 60,000–120,000 defensive gun uses per year.
RAND Corporation review (2018): Found the evidence inconclusive because of inconsistent methods.
Because of the different ways defensive gun use is reported, both sides of the argument generally agree it is hard to nail down real, solid numbers.
Many instances of defensive gun use might go unreported, usually because the weapon was only displayed, or brandished, but not fired. In many cases like this, either or both sides make a conscious decision not to involve police or the police themselves do not report it accurately since the weapon was not fired.
In other instances, defensive gun use might go unreported because both parties fled the scene and the defensive use of a weapon was not reported accurately at the moment or misatrributed.
Real-Life Case Examples
While statistics are debated, real-world cases show how concealed carry changes outcomes:
In Indiana (2022), a 22-year-old permit holder stopped a mall shooting by firing within seconds, likely saving many lives.
In Florida (2023), an armed bystander halted a convenience store robbery, forcing the suspect to drop his weapon.
One of the most subjectively documented uses of concealed carry comes from heavily surveilled areas like convenience stores, clubs, or other public and often frequented places.
Self-Defense and Concealed Carry Outcomes
Research suggests that armed victims are less likely to be injured compared to unarmed victims during an attack. A more recent study says that armed defenders are just as likely to be injured. But there are important caveats:
Even justified shootings can lead to legal battles lasting months.
Some defenders face civil lawsuits from the attacker’s family.
The burden of proof is often on the shooter to demonstrate lawful self-defense.
Regardless of whether you are more or less likely to be injured, by carrying your weapon concealed, you give yourself a chance to fight back whereas an unarmed victim might not have a chance at all if your attacker is fully prepared to harm you.
Public Safety Implications
Does concealed carry make society safer? The answer depends on perspective:
Deterrence theory: Criminals may hesitate if they believe potential victims are armed.
Public perception: A Pew survey found 72% of American gun-owners said protection is the main reason they carry a gun.
Law enforcement: Some officers value armed citizens during active shooter events, while others worry about confusion in chaotic scenes.
The truth is that the public will never have a true consensus on their opinion of gun ownership. Data can be used to argue for either side. It is up to every citizen to decide what works for them and carry responsibly.
Limitations of the Data
As previously discussed, the biggest challenge is data reliability.
Many defensive gun uses go unreported to police.
Small changes in survey wording cause huge swings in estimates.
Advocacy groups highlight statistics that favor their position, leaving the public caught between extremes.
Policy and Research Debates
The search for the right data to support what each side believes continues to fuel fierce debate. The policy fight is ongoing and will be for the foreseeable future:
Gun rights advocates: Argue concealed carry is a constitutional right and saves lives.
Gun control advocates: Warn that more guns create more risk.
State legislatures: Some move toward permitless carry, while others tighten restrictions.
Without reliable national statistics, both sides claim the data supports their case.
Conclusion & Key Takeaways
Concealed carry has undeniably stopped crimes. What remains debated is how often and at what cost.
Defensive gun use is real, but the numbers range from tens of thousands to millions annually.
Armed victims generally face lower injury rates.
Legal and civil risks remain, even in clear self-defense cases.
Communities balance between deterrence and risk of escalation.
For now, concealed carry remains both a personal safety choice and a national policy debate. It is up to every gun owner to engage with their right to bear arms in a responsible manner while understanding that the data can be unreliable.
If every gun owner strives for responsible ownership, proper training, and approaching gun ownership legally and with the right knowledge, it will lead to a strong safety and responsibility culture.
After all, statistics won’t matter when you’re confronted with an actual self-defense incident.
Frequently Asked Questions:
What do crimes stopped by concealed carry mean?
Crimes stopped by concealed carry refers to incidents where a person legally carrying a concealed firearm prevents or interrupts a crime, either by drawing, displaying, or firing their weapon in self-defense.
Most such cases don’t involve shooting—they end with a defensive display, where the potential criminal disengages when faced with an armed victim.
How many crimes are stopped by concealed carry each year?
Estimates vary widely.
National Crime Victimization Survey (NCVS): 60,000–120,000 defensive gun uses annually.
RAND Corporation (2018): Found data inconclusive due to inconsistent reporting methods.
Many concealed carry incidents go unreported because no shot is fired or both parties leave before police arrive.
Do concealed handguns reduce homicide rates?
Evidence on homicide rates and concealed handguns is mixed.
Some studies suggest that legal concealed carry laws deter violent crimes, while others find no consistent impact on homicide rates.
The difficulty lies in data reliability and inconsistent definitions of “defensive gun use” across studies.
What counts as a justifiable homicide in concealed carry cases?
A justifiable homicide occurs when a concealed firearm is used lawfully in self-defense—where the defender reasonably believes their life is in danger.
Even if the shooting is justified, the shooter may face investigation, legal scrutiny, or civil lawsuits from the attacker’s family.
Are people who carry concealed firearms safer during attacks?
Research shows mixed outcomes:
Some studies indicate that armed victims are less likely to be injured.
Others find similar injury rates between armed and unarmed victims.
However, carrying a concealed firearm gives an individual a fighting chance in a self-defense scenario compared to being unarmed.
What types of crimes are most often stopped by concealed carry?
Common crimes stopped by concealed carry include:
Robberies (e.g., store or parking-lot muggings)
Assaults and home invasions
Active shooter incidents (as seen in the Indiana mall case, 2022)
These incidents often take place in public areas under video surveillance, providing clearer documentation.
What are the legal risks of using a concealed weapon for self-defense?
Even if an act is lawful self-defense, carriers can face:
Criminal investigation or prosecution
Civil lawsuits
Emotional and financial burdens from lengthy legal processes
Proper training and understanding of carry legislation are crucial for protection under the justice system.
How do concealed carry laws vary by state?
Concealed carry legislation varies widely:
Some states allow permitless carry (constitutional carry).
Others require background checks, permits, or training.
State-level justice systems interpret defensive gun use differently, making knowledge of local laws vital.
Does concealed carry reduce overall crime rates?
The effect of concealed carry on crime rates is still debated.
Deterrence theory suggests criminals hesitate if they think victims might be armed.
Others argue more guns may increase risks of escalation or accidents.
The balance between deterrence and risk defines much of the public policy debate.
How does concealed carry relate to public safety and violence prevention?
Concealed carry fits within a broader public safety and violence prevention frame.
It can deter certain crimes but also raises questions about escalation, misidentification, and training.
Ultimately, it’s part of a community-wide justice and safety ecosystem, not a standalone solution.
Become a Right To Bear member and get the backup you can trust